Old Fashioned Tomato Ketchup

Prep Time

30m - 4h

Bake Time

1h - 2h

Yields

2 cups

About this Recipe

Bland, store-bought ketchup doesn’t hold a candle to our Old-Fashioned Tomato Ketchup. This vintage recipe originally appeared in the 1920 edition of Barrel Full of Imperial Recipes Cookbook. Referred to as “catsup” in the old days, this classic recipe is full of spice which gives it a much stronger flavor pop. While it takes a while for the tomatoes to cook down, it’s mostly hands-off and totally worth it. Your French fries will thank you.

Print this recipe

Old Fashioned Tomato Ketchup

Prep Time

30m - 4h

Bake Time

1h - 2h

Yields

2 cups

About this Recipe

Bland, store-bought ketchup doesn’t hold a candle to our Old-Fashioned Tomato Ketchup. This vintage recipe originally appeared in the 1920 edition of Barrel Full of Imperial Recipes Cookbook. Referred to as “catsup” in the old days, this classic recipe is full of spice which gives it a much stronger flavor pop. While it takes a while for the tomatoes to cook down, it’s mostly hands-off and totally worth it. Your French fries will thank you.

Print this recipe

This Recipe URL has been copied.

Ingredients

2 quarts fresh or canned tomatoes
1 onion, finely chopped
2 tablespoons salt
3 tablespoons Crystal Sugar Extra Fine Granulated Sugar
2 tablespoons dry mustard
1 tablespoon allspice
1 tablespoon black pepper
1 tablespoon cinnamon
1 teaspoon cloves
1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
1 cup apple cider vinegar

Instructions

Pour tomatoes, onion, salt, and sugar in a large pot and bring to a boil. Let mixture cook, bubbling, until thick over low/medium heat (about 1-2 hours). Remove from heat and strain out the onions and any tomato skins.
Put mixture back on heat and add spices and vinegar. Cook mixture down until thickened and most of the liquid is gone.
Pour into a container, let mixture cool for about 30 minutes, and then seal and place in fridge.
If you’d like to can/preserve the ketchup, pour into hot, sterilized jars (leaving 1/2 inch headspace) and cook in a hot water bath for 15 minutes.

Recipes for Making Memories

View all

Pumpkin Banana Muffins

Muffins Quick-and-simple

Pumpkin Banana Muffins

The cozy season is here, and what better way to celebrate than with a batch of warm, spiced Pumpkin Banana Muffins? Thes...

Brown Sugar Glazed Carrots

Brown Sugar Glazed Carrots

Add a touch of sweetness to your meal with these brown sugar glazed carrots, a simple yet elegant side dish that pairs p...

Milk Fudge or Jamoncillo de Leche

Milk Fudge or Jamoncillo de Leche

This traditional Mexican confection is a soft, sweet candy known as Mexican Milk Fudge or Jamoncillo de Leche. If you...